Welcome to CARMA’s Ninth Webcast

Dr. Zeki Simsek, Clemson University

A Framework for Methodologically Rigorous Review Articles

March 25, 2022, 12:00 pm – 1:30 pm ET

Zeki Simsek is a Professor of Management and Gressette Chair of Business Strategy and Planning at the College of Business. Prior to this appointment he held the Eversource Scholar of Technological Entrepreneurship and Ackerman Scholar at the University of Connecticut. Simsek’s research focuses on strategic leadership, innovation, and entrepreneurship. His papers regularly appear in the field’s premier outlets such as the Academy of Management Journal, Strategic Management Journal, Organization Science, Journal of Applied Psychology, and Journal of Management, among others. The New England Journal of Entrepreneurship in 2016 recognized Simsek as one of the most influential authors globally in entrepreneurship research in the 21st century as a result of his research output in top-tier management journals from 2000 to 2015. A recent analysis measuring scholarly impact in management education in the Academy of Management Learning and Education put Simsek in the top 1.6 percent out of more than 6,325 authors in the area of strategic management.

An award winning teacher, Simsek has taught executives, masters, undergraduates, and Ph.D. students. Through his venture consulting class, he and his students have provided evidenced based solutions to address the pressing problems or nascent opportunities for hundreds of small to medium-sized firms. Simsek is currently the Chair of Management Dept. TPR Committee, and has held numerous departmental, school, and university-level committees and faculty council positions. In part as recognition of these efforts across the spectrum from the school and university to community levels, and in part for his scholarly achievements, Simsek received the Research Excellence, as well as Distinguished Service awards at the University of Connecticut prior to joining Clemson in 2016. In 2019, he was also awarded a lifetime appointment to the Clemson University URSAAA society for significant achievement in research. He also won the College of Business Senior Scholar Research Excellence Award. Simsek currently teaches Strategic Management course in the MBA program, and Ph.D. Seminar in Strategic Management: Research Foundations. He also serves as an associate editor of the Academy of Management Journal, and on the editorial boards of Strategic Management Journal and Academy of Management Discoveries.


Determining what constitutes methodological rigor is a pre-requisite to doing rigorous review articles. In this webcast, I present a framework for understanding and evaluating the key components of methodological rigor across review types. The underlying premise is that even as methodological rigor can differ from one review type to another, achieving a high degree of alignment among the review type, purpose, and systematicity is the essential foundation. I elaborate upon that premise and conclude with some practical suggestions for conducting rigorous reviews. Researchers preparing or interested in preparing review articles and evaluators and readers of review articles might find the webcast informative and valuable.

Access Information

  • No registration is needed.
  • Login to your CARMA account.
  • Once you login, in the middle, you will see a section “Active Meetings”.
  • You will see the access link one hour before the event in this section.

Quick Chat with Dr. Zeki Simsek

Upcoming CARMA Events

  • March 25, 2022 – Topic Interest Group
  • April 8, 2022 – Webcast, Dr. Mo Wang, Longitudinal Latent Variable Analysis
  • April 8, 2022 – PhD Prep Group
  • April 22, 2022 – Topic Interest Group